Moviepedia:Requests for Comment/Requests for Comment:Copyright Crew Group

Closed as unsuccessful, 2 Opposes, 0 supports, 0 Neutral. -Involved closure. Consensus is clear. Justarandomamerican (talk) 20:12, 27 November 2021 (UTC)

i was thinking we should create a new copyright team because as admin and crates have other things to do we wont have time we also get alot of copy and past pages and i think its time we start a team of volunteers to help with this, a new group although this might not seem as a good idea i think we could also make policy's to making this new team along with policy's

= Proposal 1: = We should create a group called copyright team, as the admin and crates can not always be around to deal with copyright and a lot of copyright occurs i think we should create a group that can take care of this small bit of the wiki giving admin and Bureaucrat a  chance to take care of other things, i think making this group is also gonna help us with preventing more copyright contents from occurring.

Oppose

 * 1) I'd like to defer to local community because I am not much of a member and I may never be, but I'll reiterate my comments elsewhere that the lack of membership leaves this group as an unnecessary bloat. I am not convinced that the admins are overworked enough to handle the very rare possible copyright issue, which shouldn't happen if the wiki operates like a normal one. The traffic makes regular patrolling more than easy enough to do by admins themselves, but if you insist perhaps find some worthwhile members to delegate patroller to and have patrollers keep an eye out for anything that's odd, including potential copyright issue. Thus you can delegate the hunting to others and admins need only go 'yes' or 'no' and make a final action. This title is additionally so specific that it is a little baffling. Even for Miraheze itself, copyright (legal) issue is part of the broader Trust & Safety department, rather than its singular goal. --Raidarr (talk) 08:56, 12 September 2021 (UTC)

Comments
= Proposal 2: = we should not only make this group but give them certain permissions to take care of copyright issues such as deleting, copyright tagging tool and of course permission to suppress copyright pages and images  so here is my proposal


 * this group will only be allowed to delete pages within copyright
 * The group is not allowed to take on other rank task
 * the group is limited to what actions they are allowed to do with a clear point of what is allowed

Support

Oppose
, on the basis of how much work it would be to have every member of this group take on a local steward-like election for suppression rights. If this wiki was hosted somewhere else, I would not be opposed to this. Plus, the consensus for proposal 1 is not to create the group. Justarandomamerican (talk) 17:55, 22 November 2021 (UTC)